Slashdot is powered by your submissions, so send in your scoop

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
Apple

Trump Tells Apple CEO To Avoid Manufacturing in India (livemint.com) 225

U.S. President Donald Trump said he has told Apple CEO Tim Cook to stop expanding manufacturing operations in India despite New Delhi offering a "no-tariff deal" to the United States, a move that could impede India's aspirations to become a global technology manufacturing hub.

"I had a little problem with Tim Cook yesterday," Trump said during his state visit to Qatar, referring to the Apple chief executive. "He is building all over India. I don't want you building in India. India can take care of itself."

Apple has significantly increased its Indian manufacturing footprint, assembling $22 billion worth of iPhones in India during the 12 months through March. Apple said earlier this month a majority of its devices shipped into the U.S. in the June quarter will originate in India and Vietnam.

Trump Tells Apple CEO To Avoid Manufacturing in India

Comments Filter:
  • Good jorb, don (Score:4, Interesting)

    by Mr. Dollar Ton ( 5495648 ) on Thursday May 15, 2025 @04:33AM (#65377965)

    Won't it be ironic if the US president kills the most valuable US business?

    • Re: (Score:3, Insightful)

      by geekmux ( 1040042 )

      Won't it be ironic if the US president kills the most valuable US business?

      Apple has significantly increased its Indian manufacturing footprint, assembling $22 billion worth of iPhones in India during the 12 months through March..

      One does not pull $22 billion worth of manufactured goods out of ones ass overnight. Or since Inauguration Day, 2025. Not a damn thing DJT has ever said or done, created Apple manufacturing in India. Which has clearly been going on for a while.

      Wouldn’t it be ironic if the country that practically invented clickbait bullshit, decided to start remembering what is actually valuable instead of perpetuating clickbait bullshit?

      • So what is actually valuable in your esteemed opinion?

        Obviously what is actually valuable to Apple is to be able to produce its trinkets where the costs are minimal and the output quantities can satisfy their market demand.

        • As it turns out, that is also quite valuable to Apple's customers, as they don't want the price for Apple's trinkets to go any higher.

          This was always going to be the result of his idiot trade war. No CEO that deserves to hold the position is going to say "oh well I guess we're done with manufacturing in the world's cheap labor markets because a dottering old orange man said so. I guess we'll have to manufacture in the world's most expensive labor market instead. and jack our prices up, or shrink our margi

      • Re:Good jorb, don (Score:4, Interesting)

        by Njovich ( 553857 ) on Thursday May 15, 2025 @05:21AM (#65378035)

        Let me preface this by saying there is no way Apple with get killed by this.

        One does not pull $22 billion worth of manufactured goods out of ones ass overnight. Or since Inauguration Day, 2025.

        Guess when these decisions happened and who was president then: https://www.reuters.com/articl... [reuters.com]
        And now again Apple is expanding in India with Donnie boy being president again.

        Not a damn thing DJT has ever said or done, created Apple manufacturing in India.

        Actually, yeah he kind of did. By setting off a trade war with China: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/... [wikipedia.org]
        This made many US companies move manufacturing elsewhere, including this Apple move to India

        • by Bert64 ( 520050 )

          Well that's the typical unintended consequences. Placing punitive tariffs on china was never going to force manufacturing back to the US, it was only ever going to bump it to the next cheapest country.
          You'd need to have punitive tariffs on *ALL* countries where manufacturing is significantly cheaper than the US.

          And even if final manufacturing takes place in the US, many of the parts still come from other countries so you'd have not only the higher assembly costs but you'd also still be hit with tariffs on t

          • Re:Good jorb, don (Score:5, Interesting)

            by gtall ( 79522 ) on Thursday May 15, 2025 @06:40AM (#65378159)

            Let's look at la Presidenta's record of running a successful business. Squat. He is good at running fraudulent businesses (see the NY State court case or his "University"). There's only the faintest of fuzzy chances his latest "scheme" to bring manufacturing "back" to America will work.

            First, components get sourced from all over, attempting to make them all the U.S. is just plain silly.

            Second, any manufacturing "brought" back will be so automated that the number of jobs it creates is minimal. That means the Maggots get nothing for this pump and dump scheme so there is not sustainable support for it.

            Third, other countries will continue to produce what they are good at, so any manufacturing "brought" back to America will still not be able to compete globally against those other countries.

            Forth, the tariffs will need to continue to be in place to protect those the new expensive (to the rest of the world) manufacturing.

            Fifth, the increase in cost will be born by America consumers (since they won't be selling their new manufactured shit abroad as it is too expensive). They are already livid at the cost of living, this will only make it worse.

            Sixth, the haphazard and meandering whims of the la Presidenta make companies not want to invest in new manufacturing in the U.S. since the rug could get pulled out from under them at any time, say when la Presidenta gots pissed at broken marshmallows in his breakfast feed, the phase of the moon not conforming to what he thinks it should be, etc.

            Seventh, la Presidenta will go the way of the dodo in 2028, if not before due to his familial familiarity with dementia, or due to his heart climbing up and strangling his two brain cells for causing him to shovel large amounts of McDonald's "fry-my-heart" food down his pie hole.

            • Re: (Score:2, Insightful)

              by Bert64 ( 520050 )

              Yes, there's lots of flaws in the current approach, but that wasn't my point.

              The point is the *goal* is a valid one, the method of achieving it doesn't look too good but there also don't seem to be any better options on the table.

              If you keep outsourcing everything to cheaper places then eventually there will be no jobs in the US, and people simply won't be able to afford the resulting products. Then it doesn't matter how cheap the manufacturing is, you can't sell. The economy will collapse, and this would l

              • Re:Good jorb, don (Score:5, Insightful)

                by null etc. ( 524767 ) on Thursday May 15, 2025 @09:22AM (#65378449)

                If you keep outsourcing everything to cheaper places then eventually there will be no jobs in the US

                No, the reason why there will be no jobs in the US eventually is that the upper class has become increasingly effective at waging class warfare against the middle and lower classes, who have become increasingly ineffective at fighting back. The rich will always find a way to squeeze profit out of those who are less well-off.

              • US unemployment rate was about 4% by January 2025.
                https://tradingeconomics.com/u... [tradingeconomics.com]

                That's about as low as it can get without causing undesirable side effects.

                So what exactly is the problem?
                You want to give up your job coding to sew t-shirts?
                You want to put your kids to work in factories gluing sneakers?
                You want your senior citizens to put screws in iphone cases?

                What problem is he solving?

            • Re:Good jorb, don (Score:5, Informative)

              by Gilmoure ( 18428 ) on Thursday May 15, 2025 @09:23AM (#65378455) Journal

              All these tarifs are are stock market manipulation tools.

              He's getting a kick about being able to jerk the stock markets around while he and his cronies inside trade.

          • I agree with you up until you say "there won't be anyone left to actually buy the finished products".

            The thing with those tariffs and the imbalance of trade is it NEVER FACTORS IN SERVICE. And guess what, the US is predominantly a service economy. That's what Google, Amazon, Microsoft, etc. are. If you take service into account, the US exports more than it imports with many countries. Why would I want to repatriate all the manufacturing jobs, when instead I can create software or be in professional servic
            • Why would I want to repatriate all the manufacturing jobs, when instead I can create software or be in professional services? At the end of the day, iPhone manufacturing is a bunch of folks hunched over a table with soldering irons, paid at minimum wage or close if it was here. You want to do that?

              The problem with everything being manufactured outside the US is if the supply dries out. We've seen that with Covid, and we're seeing it now. If there's an unusual situation (or god forbid, war), you won't have

      • Re:Good jorb, don (Score:4, Interesting)

        by Antique Geekmeister ( 740220 ) on Thursday May 15, 2025 @06:22AM (#65378139)

        Unless, of course, you're giving $400,000,000 of airplane as a bribe to Trump.

    • Re:Good jorb, don (Score:5, Insightful)

      by AmiMoJo ( 196126 ) on Thursday May 15, 2025 @05:15AM (#65378029) Homepage Journal

      The funniest thing is all the MAGA whining about everything being communist, until the 34 time felon starts giving companies direct orders with the threat of retaliation if they don't comply.

      • Re:Good jorb, don (Score:5, Insightful)

        by Mr. Dollar Ton ( 5495648 ) on Thursday May 15, 2025 @05:37AM (#65378065)

        Conservatism is not about "sharing", it is about keeping what's yours and getting more, never mind the direct or the opportunity costs. Therefore this isn't technically "Communism", it is its antithesis, the plain old fascism. Or, as the popular slogan once said, "In a Capitalist society, a man is exploited by his fellow man. In a Communist society, it is the other way around".

        But I have a question - are the conservative MAGATs so different from their previous incarnations as teabaggers, neocons, reaganites, nixonites and so on?

        • > Conservatism is not about "sharing", it is about keeping what's yours and getting more, never mind the direct or the opportunity costs.

          You're calling Apple 'conservative' for not sharing profits with the workers in the country where they have the most direct employees?

          Nobody thinks Apple is Conservative, except for that white 'power' logo they blazed for a couple decades.

      • by mjwx ( 966435 )

        The funniest thing is all the MAGA whining about everything being communist, until the 34 time felon starts giving companies direct orders with the threat of retaliation if they don't comply.

        As much as your point is valid, that is not strictly communism, its a symptom of totalitarianism which doesn't have a left or right wing bend. The far right has a history of totalitarianism, we called that philosophy "fascism" (see also: theocracy).

      • by 0xG ( 712423 )

        So tell me, my American friends:

        How are you enjoying 'rule by decree'?

      • Re:Good jorb, don (Score:4, Informative)

        by MachineShedFred ( 621896 ) on Thursday May 15, 2025 @12:15PM (#65378873) Journal

        This is where populism always leads to, because it's not anchored in anything.

        MAGA has not been conservative for quite some time, outside of using "conservative" as a brand. These "conservatives" are responsible for the largest middle-class tax hike in modern history. These "conservatives" are not following the plain words of the Constitution. These "conservatives" are looking to add $4T to the national debt by slashing social services to the bone while giving billionaires a tax cut.

        Ok maybe that last bit is somewhat "conservative" but it's also political suicide, which is why you see some Republican Senators starting to say so. We're about two weeks from the 2026 fiscal omnibus "big beautiful bill" collapsing and forcing the Congress to deliver yet another continuing resolution extending Biden's spending because they can't actually agree on anything and pass it, because there is no philosophical anchor to what they are doing.

    • > Won't it be ironic if the US president kills the most valuable US business?

      Isn't Apple an Irish business with an R&D center in California now?

      They hardly pay any US corporate taxes.

    • Won't it be ironic if the US president kills the most valuable US business?

      No. It would be just one more sign that he did what he was paid to do.

    • by Gilmoure ( 18428 )

      I'm just trying to imagine Tim's reaction when he first gets the news.

      "He said WHAT?!!"

  • by SeaFox ( 739806 ) on Thursday May 15, 2025 @04:48AM (#65377971)

    "He is building all over India. I don't want you building in India."

    Interesting. Imagine the uproar of a Democrat President tried to dictate to private businesses who they could partner with for manufacturing.

    • by martin-boundary ( 547041 ) on Thursday May 15, 2025 @04:53AM (#65377981)
      It's all part of the 5 year economic plan you see. Democrats are opposed to state based command economies. They only want to let the private companies make their own decisions.
    • Re: (Score:3, Insightful)

      by RobinH ( 124750 )
      You joke, but the US is in the middle of a political party shakeup that happens every half-century or so. For all of my life the social conservatives (i.e. devout Christians) and the business community made up the core of the Republican party, and the Democratic party was a loose coalition of other groups, but their backbone was organized labor and minorities. A sizeable chunk of organized labor and even some minority vote has now moved over to the Republican side (because of Trump) and the business commu
      • the remainder of the Democrat base rejected them as not pure enough,

        The Democratic base is not a left/right mirror image of the Republican base. The Democratic base is not online leftists, who again and again are revealed in every single party contest of every kind to be powerless and outnumbered. The actual Democratic base is boring centrists that love Barack Obama, Bill Clinton, Joe Biden, and Kamala Harris, and have supported corporations for decades.

      • by skam240 ( 789197 ) on Thursday May 15, 2025 @11:09AM (#65378707)

        and the rest of America trashed them for, e.g. the Gillette commercial, the Bud Light fiasco

        It's funny how you brought conservatives pitching a fit about commercials into this like that's some kind of major thing most of America would have cared about if the talking heads on Fox hadn't told them to get upset.

  • Pot, Kettle, Black (Score:5, Insightful)

    by Gravis Zero ( 934156 ) on Thursday May 15, 2025 @04:55AM (#65377987)

    Why is Trump telling Apple to bot use overseas labor when Trump is the guy who has all his merch made in China? If I didn't know any better (and I don't) then I would say he's a massive hypocrite (because he is).

    • Even he will probably have to move his merch production to some other country besides China, depending on the conclusion of the tariff tiff. Meanwhile, you're asking the wrong question.

      Why is Trump warning Apple not to use India, without mentioning any other country that they use (such as Vietnam)? Is he expecting India to be embroiled in a protracted war with Pakistan?

    • He's not a hypocrite, he just likes RUMP.

      https://www.kwtx.com/2025/05/1... [kwtx.com]

    • ... Trump telling Apple ...

      1) IIRC, Apple didn't pay the inauguration-party 'donation': Time for increasing threats until they pay.
      2) Trump needs to keep Fox News distracted, since they've started admitting more and more truths.
      3) MAGA needs to be reminded that he's bringing jobs to the USA, so time to pretend he is 'making' jobs.

  • Economic illiterate (Score:5, Interesting)

    by Going_Digital ( 1485615 ) on Thursday May 15, 2025 @05:04AM (#65378003)
    An Indian employee doing a mind numbingly boring job on a production line earns $3 per hour? Even the dumbest high school drop out is going to cost $30 per hour with the laws designed to protect workers. So which is it that Trump wants?

    For US citizens to pay more for their Apple tech than any other country in the world?

    For Apple to charge the same but make no profit and go out of business?

    To cut all US worker protections and turn the country into a 3rd world country paying workers $3 an hour?

    One or more of these things will happen if companies like Apple are forced to manufacture in the USA. I do happen to agree that western countries have become too reliant on low cost Asian manufacturing, but Trump just has no idea how to solve that. You don't act like some kind of god, that when you decry it, it happens. It requires a well thought out plan that identifies key areas that can be re-developed in the USA. Trump will tank the US economy on his crusade.

    • Apple products are so expensive that going from $3/hr to $30/hr wouldn't move the peg much. Also there are still places in the US paying $15-$20 for low level manufacturing/warehouse work. Chamber of Commerce types love that shit. Competitive wages!

      • What are you talking about? Their current price has nothing to do with it. Higher costs to manufacture will be recouped one way or another.
        • How many man hours do you think it takes to produce an iPhone, not counting costs folded into BoM or design/r&d? Or to be more clear, what's the current labor cost associated with producing a new iPhone 17 pro max in India?

      • One thing to remember is even if the wage paid is $15/hr in the US any full time employment comes with a host of other taxes and obligations that are invisible to the employee but real to the company. When I've been involved in hiring the rule of thumb I was given was take the base salary and assume total cost to the company is 150% to 200% of that.

        It's one of the reasons gig work is pushed so hard, you can circumvent a lot of that and push it back on the employee.

    • by jvkjvk ( 102057 )

      >To cut all US worker protections and turn the country into a 3rd world country paying workers $3 an hour?

      Those all fall into that nasty no-good category of "Regulations". Which are bad. Totally bad and disgusting. Why would you want any of *those* hanging around impeding profits?

      No, best to get rid of those forthwith.

  • Uncertainty (Score:5, Insightful)

    by simlox ( 6576120 ) on Thursday May 15, 2025 @05:08AM (#65378011)
    kills all investments. Nobody wants to build factories for the US market anywhere now: If the tariffs are there to stay, you must build them in the US, but if they are removed before your factory is up and running, you will have a too expensive manufacturing in the US. So everybody wants. Except businesses who don't care about the US market anyway, they will just try to avoid US suppliers from now on. It is basically a loose-loose strategy for the US right now.
  • by Savage-Rabbit ( 308260 ) on Thursday May 15, 2025 @05:44AM (#65378075)

    Trump Tells Apple CEO To Avoid Manufacturing in India.

    I just had a meeting, with Tim Apple, and we're going to bring back jobs, lots of jobs, screwing those little screws into iPhones, a bigly beautiful flood of minimum wage jobs, y'know, for the little people - that kind of thing is going to come to America now, lots of it, more of it than anything else ever, in history. Then, when the little people have screwed screws into iPhones for 12 hours, they can take a night shift at McDonalds and then work all weekend at Chick-Fil-A just to put food on the table. It's going to be awesome, bleeve me! Bleeve me!!

  • Remind me (Score:5, Insightful)

    by quonset ( 4839537 ) on Thursday May 15, 2025 @06:09AM (#65378119)

    What is it called when a government dictates to private industry how and where to run its business?

  • by jvkjvk ( 102057 ) on Thursday May 15, 2025 @06:20AM (#65378131)

    What is he prepared to do about it?

    He talks a good game but folds most of the time any pressure is kept up.

    • > What is he prepared to do about it?

      It ain't right but Apple's App Store monopoly might just get broken up if they insist on moving manufacturing to India.

      It's actually interesting because last year they were saying China was the only option because you can get every size screw any time day or night because China was so specialized.

      Now India has all that? Nope, it was never true, supply chain logistics are sufficient.

      • by dfghjk ( 711126 )

        LOL Trump breaking up a monopoly. And if it's a monopoly, why would it not be right to break it up? Do you not believe in free markets?

        "It's actually interesting because last year they were saying China was the only option because you can get every size screw any time day or night because China was so specialized."

        Who was saying this? Citation please. Chinese manufacturing is "so specialized"? Because they can manufacture anything?

        "Now India has all that? Nope, it was never true, supply chain logistics

  • Noselength (Score:4, Insightful)

    by Fons_de_spons ( 1311177 ) on Thursday May 15, 2025 @06:40AM (#65378157)
    Trump puts heavy tariffs on China to nudge manufacturers to move the the US. Then he exempts India for whatever reason. Result: Manufacturers move to India where labor is cheaper than in the US.

    In Dutch, we have a saying: "He can't see further than his nose". Is he really that stupid? Hard to imagine... Oh well, let him clean up his own mess.
    • Apple has been looking to diversify the countries they operate and manufacture in for some time. Indias prior demand to have iPhone manufacturing there is not something new. Apple also have manufacturing in Vietnam for instance. China is turning more and more authoritarian towards external companies while promoting internal brands. So itâ(TM)s obvious Apple is trying to limit their presence there.
  • The political leader dictates what companies should do... seems a bit against the free market economy the West is based on!!

  • The brutal truth (Score:5, Insightful)

    by Inglix the Mad ( 576601 ) on Thursday May 15, 2025 @08:05AM (#65378269)
    At this point most companies would should just ignore him in general. He changes his mind every time the breeze changes anyway, so just make nice sounds and talk about all the stuff you might do in the future. Why? Because all he cares about are sound bites he can post to social media and spout in the news. You give him a nice sound bite he'll ignore what you're really doing and call any press pointing it out fake news.

    Then MAGAt Maggie and Tommy Trumper can point at that to own the libz.
  • Hardly. He may fake something for a while, but that is it.

  • If the Orange Dictator says "don't manufacture in India", you'd better "don't manufacture in India", else said Orange Dictator will get angry and use whatever means he has at his disposal, legal or otherwise, to make life difficult for you. How there isn't uproar, I don't know.

  • Except when we say no for whatever bs political reasons, like getting the grift.
  • ...than telling a private company to curtail their overseas operations? It makes total sense; let's just order all private companies that they can either set up shop solely in America, or GTFO.
  • It is odd, though... (Score:4, Interesting)

    by bradley13 ( 1118935 ) on Thursday May 15, 2025 @10:20AM (#65378599) Homepage

    Modern factories to produce electronic devices are almost entirely automated, especially for high-volume products. Labor costs are pretty minimal. Just yesterday I toured an electronics factory here in Switzerland - where labor costs are considerably higher than in the US. The factory has a number of US customers.

    So, serious question: why don't US companies like Apple build their factories in the US?

My sister opened a computer store in Hawaii. She sells C shells down by the seashore.

Working...