Apple Is Working on a 16-Inch iPad, Further Blurring Line With Laptops (theinformation.com) 65
Wayne Ma, reporting for The Information: Apple is developing its largest iPad yet, a model with a 16-inch screen that it hopes to release in the fourth quarter of next year, according to a person familiar with the project. The device would further blur the line between the iPad and MacBook, bringing the tablet's screen size in line with that of Apple's largest laptop, which also features a 16-inch display. Apple's biggest iPad currently sports a 12.9-inch screen.
Does it run desktop software? (Score:4, Insightful)
The only way I'd care what an iPad does is if it ran desktop software. I can watch Netflix, but on a bigger and more expensive device, sure, but those things still don't even have a functional file manager or window management.
Re: (Score:3, Informative)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: Does it run desktop software? (Score:4, Interesting)
To be fair, android used to present itself as a USB storage device so copying image, music etc files on and off was simple. Then google decided that was too useful and switched to some obscure USB protocol that requires non standard support. Linux (well KDE) has some half assed app that sort of works but MacOS cant speak it so it's not just apple playing these lets-be-arseholes games and screw the customer.
Re: Does it run desktop software? (Score:2)
The problem with UMS is it requires exclusive access, and it's prone to file system corruption. What they needed was a way to abstract the file system, much like a network share. Problem is, the aren't many that don't also require a ton of effort for the user to set up just to do USB file transfers. They went with MTP because even though it's shit, at least Windows computers support it out of the box, which is what the vast majority would be using anyways.
Re: (Score:2)
MTP has proven to be super terrible but there was a good reason - with USB Storage support the storage had to be either mounted on the phone or mounted on the computer/device, it couldn't be both. This wasn't a problem in older devices where the SD Card was mostly just bulk storage for pictures, videos, music, etc but got to be a bigger problem once it was being used for apps, app data, and things the phone needed access to all the time. The phone didn't really care if your pics and media and such went away
Re: Does it run desktop software? (Score:3)
NFS , SMB etc all solved the multi access race condition problem decades ago.
Re: (Score:2)
> since no usb thumbdrives work on a iphone
Since when?
It's been a while since I paid attention, but I recall many years ago flash drives specifically designed to work with iPhones and iPads, usually with an iPlug on one end and USB-A on the other so it could be used with other devices too. And I could swear there were also adapters for standard flash drives.
Though... there might have been some specialty software involved - I do recall them being a nuisance.
Re: (Score:2)
Re:Does it run desktop software? (Score:5, Informative)
It has file MANAGEMENT, yes, but it does NOT have a file MANAGER, because it does not expose a proper file system to user land, which is what people want. This is a purposeful design choice by Apple, and we can debate whether it's a good one or not, but it is what it is, and you'll never have a PROPER file manager as a result, you'll always have some kneecapped app.
And when you say it can run Office, photo edit software and sound/movie production, that's true in a general sense, but again, it's not what people mean. They mean it can't run the FULL desktop versions of this stuff, and that's true. You're not running a FULL version of Office, for example, you're still running a trimmed-down "mobile" version. You're not running a FULL version of Photoshop, or Cubase, or Final Cut, you're running trimmed-down versions. And, again, we can debate whether this is good or bad, whether they have 99% of what most people need 99% of the time and therefore could effectively be considered "full", but it again is what it is by design.
Re: (Score:3)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Ok, I may be an old fart by how is running your data through "the cloud" more secure than doing everything locally on the device?
Re: (Score:2)
Android (and I think also Ios) apps are isolated by default: one cannot access documents from the other, unless you allow them to explicitly via the 'share' mechanism. This closes the loophole that a malicious app can read and write all your files. And this loophole is to blame for most viruses and ransomware attacks that are still rampant.
Re: (Score:2)
1. It DOES have a file manager, the only difference to MacOS/Windows/Linux is that it only allows you to "manage" files that are in specific areas designated for users purpose only. You can still create/edit/delete folders, arrange them, etc. You just can't touch parts of the filesystem that can potentially do harmful things to the OS.
2. The applications on iPad are actually NOT trimmed-down versions. They are
Re: (Score:3)
It certainly does... Nowadays the iPad can run things like MS Office, Photo edit software, sound/movie production. It already has file management a long time ago, not only on iPad but on iPhone too.
Like the legit full x64 versions of the software? Or the hobbled web version?
Re:Does it run desktop software? (Score:4, Informative)
A limited version. Definitely not as usable as Office on arm64 or amd64. It can do the basics, and usable in a pinch, but the workflows are quite limited one can use with it. It is usable, but definitely limited compared to the macOS or Windows versions.
Re: (Score:2)
My Windows Mobile PDA ran Excel and Word, among other things, back in 2003. So I guess it's nice to see Apple catching up!
And of course Apple as always inventing a new thing, very courageously: https://www.youtube.com/watch?... [youtube.com]
Doesn't run Lightroom, MS Surface does! (Score:3)
It certainly does... Nowadays the iPad can run things like MS Office, Photo edit software, sound/movie production. It already has file management a long time ago, not only on iPad but on iPhone too.
You can say that all you want, but the professional-grade photo editing doesn't run on it. That's Adobe's fault, not Apple's, but if you're a professional photographer, you're better served by buying a Microsoft Surface. Apple has a had a long time to solve this and I am not impressed by their progress. Microsoft has had a nice tablet that can run anything you want: your favorite video games, development environments, professional apps, etc for 10 years.
The iPad has long been a giant phone in terms
Re: (Score:3)
I have an iPad Pro that I use extensively and I quite like it for specific purposes, mostly viewing and modifying media, pdf documents, and ebooks.
iPad is extremely limited compared to Win/Linux/Mac. Biggest issue is Apple's condescending approach to what is allowed to be run on the device not the least of which is no competitive web browsers. Well, they let you tweak the presentation layer but it is all Apple under the skin complete with all of Safari's bugs. Doesn't take long after purchase before you
Re: (Score:2)
The only way I'd care what an iPad does is if it ran desktop software.
Yep, use the best tool for the job. End of story.
If you're interested in why I'd want one I'll explain- It's kinda like having a Cintiq in a very power-efficient portable form factor. I have a job where being able to use a stylus like this is very helpful AND since I work from home I can sit in my more comfortable recliner while doing said work. Additionally when the iPad went USB-C it also brought along mouse support, networking support, access to flash/hard drives etc. A larger iPad would be more th
Re: (Score:2)
Sorry for replying to myself but there are downsides to it and I figure I should mention those. First is that its multitasking is... well it's there but it's not like using a laptop. It really is more appliance-like. That works to my benefit since I use tools that are memory hungry, but it does mean if I need to talk with someone at work while I'm doing work on my iPad it can get awkward. In my case I end up getting my phone out instead of flipping tasks on the iPad. (I have reasons why the split-scre
Re:Does it run desktop software? (Score:4, Interesting)
I have one as well, and it is a good niche item. When I go on work trips, I bring it along, because it is all I need for personal stuff. It also is inherently more secure than a general purpose laptop, so if it gets lost or stolen, it will be harder for an unauthorized party to get data from it, especially with the "erase after 10 attempts" dialog is turned on, or similar is pushed via the MDM. The 10" version is also a lot easier to carry around and toss in a pocket of a backpack as opposed to a full-fledged laptop, even with a keyboard case. It also is useful for drawing and other stuff (music production).
At home, it is a good third screen, where I can monitor stuff with it using SideCar, leave it separate and play movies on it, or whatnot.
Definitely not something that everything needs, but for what it does, as a limited purpose accessory, as opposed to a general purpose computer, it works well.
Re: (Score:2)
Yeah. My biggest complaint against iPads, and nice Android tablets as well for that matter, is that they're a limited purpose accessory for the price of a full-function PC.
If you have a sufficiently valuable niche for such a thing (or don't really have a use for a full-function PC), I suppose they're great.
Re: (Score:3)
A lot of what we call Desktop Software, has been available on Tables and Phone devices for a while now. Most new software often has the Mobile App developed first, with the Desktop app being a crappy port of the mobile app, or just a web page.
If you add a mouse and keyboard, to the mobile device, there isn't much you cant do on a mobile system, then on an actual Desktop or Laptop.
Now in terms of desktop type stuff. I would say Android is better suited than Apple, as you can actually gain access to the She
Re: (Score:3)
How long it been since you touched an iPad? I've written novels on iPads (Scrivener, Word, Pages) and done finances (Excel and Numbers). iPads have been blurring the desktop line for quite some time. The file manager has been around for years at this point. It's not perfect, but it certainly exists.
Re: (Score:1)
Also another big problem is the browser support. Apple mandates all browsers to use safari webwiev as their engine.
Apple should make it dual boot from the factory (Score:1)
Re: (Score:2)
macOS can already run iOS apps on the ARM Macs, so there's not much point to dual-booting if they wanted to allow both. Would just need a little work to better enable macOS for touch, or at least an interface that looks/works more like iPadOS but allows better window and application management.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
You can't count on mouse and keyboard on a tablet though.
But you could probably get a good 90% solution by just increasing the size of UI elements like title and scroll bars when a mouse isn't connected. And maybe some sort of pop-up on-screen touchpad when needed for precision work. (Everyone knows the finger-rolling trick for precision control with a touchpad, right?)
Re: (Score:2)
I just wish more app developers would allow iOS/iPadOS apps to run on macOS. Encapsulated stuff that I don't really care about workflows in and out, apps are nice, just because of the added security.
Gonna need even bigger pants (Score:2)
Clothing manufacturers everywhere rejoice.
Re: (Score:2)
Apple: Please let it have cellular (Score:2)
So that I can get rid of my phone and just use one massive device to do everything.
Or make smaller phones, that would be OK, too.
Re: (Score:2)
So that I can get rid of my phone and just use one massive device to do everything.
https://cdn.mos.cms.futurecdn.... [futurecdn.net]
Re: (Score:3)
Blur what line exactly? (Score:2)
Even a TRS-80 model 100 is a laptop.
Since the linked article is a paywall, I can only see the top half of what I assume to be the new product - does it have a keyboard or something?
Re: (Score:2)
Yeah, that line doesn't seem to be too blurry.
"Does it have a keyboard? No? Ok...that's not a laptop. Is is just a touchscreen, with no keyboard? Yep...that's a tablet"
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
It's a combination of the hardware and the software though. Yes you can connect a keyboard and mouse/trackpad to the iPad but it wasn't designed for that so it doesn't really work very well, likewise you can run Linux Mint on a Surface Pro but if you try to use it as a tablet rather than with the keyboard and mouse/trackpad it doesn't really work.
A physical keyboard replaces a virtual keyboard quite well but also the OS isn't designed with an always-available keyboard in mind, for example the shortcuts are
Get glasses (Score:2)
iOS is still to hobbled to do anything but COMSUME
Re: (Score:2)
I'm pretty sure that even if you have 20/20 vision you would be able to use a 16in device. You may not need to use a device that large but if you have "perfect" vision then a larger screen shouldn't be any harder to see than a small screen.
This is the one I was waiting for. (Score:3)
This is the one I was waiting for. (and will wait for)
As big as a standard music book. Me and my nearly blind piano teacher are gonna love this.
I have a 12.9 and while it's replaced my 3-ring binder full of music, it's also become my book bag and manga bookcase.
But for what I do with these things, bigger is better. It's not goign to be some cut-down laptop for me, it's going to be a glorified music book. Just like my current one is.
And I'm fine with that.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:3)
You can obviously scan all the sheet music into electronic form, I wonder if there is any input device like a pedal you could use to turn the page on a tablet without moving your hands away from the keyboard.
tons. Some cheap, some not so cheap, some with regular batteries, some with li-ion. Mine just uses a 9v or a standard effects power supply. It's called the "Stomp" just search for "bluetooth page turner" and you'll have a range of choices.
Also, the software I use, "ForScore," has a thing where you can use facial gestures to turn pages. haven't used that feature yet.
the best part is, you can write all over your music without harming the original.
Be careful with forscore, the 13.1 update in sept broke la
Re: (Score:2)
Or...
I'm sure you've seen those novelty "blow out the candle" type apps where you blow on the mic? That might actually be a really convenient hands-free page turning mechanic. Maybe with a double-puff for "back", just in case?
I'm sure the burst of white noise is relatively easy to pick out from most background noise... the biggest challenge would probably be ignoring applause, and even a quick smattering is likely to last a lot longer than an air puff.
If anyone uses the idea I expect to get at least a cou
Re: (Score:3)
Hmm, further idea - don't flip the page all at once, instead use something like a "scroll unrolling down the page" animation, with a pause for a second page-flip signal halfway down, so that you can see the top half of the next page (what's coming up) while still reading the bottom row(s) of the current page. I know making that blind jump between pages was always a bit of an extra challenge. A half-page pause would also be more robust against any mistaken page-flipping signals
ForScore alreayd has that half-page-turn thing. It was controversial when adopted. I don't use it
I'm sure you've seen those novelty "blow out the candle" type apps where you blow on the mic? That might actually be a really convenient hands-free page turning mechanic. Maybe with a double-puff for "back", just in case?
o.O I'd like to see that on a live-on-tv recital or something.. blow on the page (screen) to make it flip..n.n
Can't be any stranger than someone winking at the screen or whatever facial gesture one chooses to "page right" and such.
I just use my foot trigger. Or even my finger, if I know the piece well enough to buffer some of it in my brain
Re: (Score:2)
Even better if they're flipping paper pages that way, that takes real skill!
But I'd bet it'd be a lot less noticeable, with a lot fewer false positives, than any facial gestures. After all, if the music isn't moving through you, including your face, are you really *playing* it, or just soullessly going through the motions like any 90s midi software could?
One of the things that always pissed me off with most music classes was that they tried to make you play the music exactly as written, even going so far a
Re: (Score:2)
Interesting. Many musicians require page-turners for their sheet music. You can obviously scan all the sheet music into electronic form, I wonder if there is any input device like a pedal you could use to turn the page on a tablet without moving your hands away from the keyboard.
There are plenty. Bluetooth. They work great!
Demographics (Score:2)
Skeptical of durability... (Score:3)
I had a Pro a few years back - 12.9? Too lazy to look it up. Over time it ended up slowly bending until the screen and the back separated. "Physical damage" they said. Well... yeah. But not through abuse.
I'd be concerned that a flat device that large would have to really be coddled, or suffer a similar outcome. You'd always have to two-hand it, lest you stress it.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:3)
No... it was not a battery issue. It was simply physical. As the unit continued to "droop", it was clear that eventually the seam would give. And it did. Apparently I'm not alone. Just googled it, and there are lots of similar stories. After the separation (and crack), and before I junked it, I pulled it apart out of curiosity. Battery was fine.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
with Samsung making a 14 inch tablet with s-pen (Score:2)
is normal that apple will follow
how many ports? (Score:2)
Still just one? Or will this one cross the line to none?
If it runs OSX... (Score:2)
if only it had proper network file access (Score:1)
without screwing about
Form factor matters to me (Score:3)
I own four tablets, and get a decent amount of use out of two of them. I almost forgot about one of them, an Amazon Fire HD 8" that I bought in 2017 partly because it was on a heavy sale. Excellent optimization by Amazon, but I just use it as a backup.
Anyway, long story short, while my Samsung Galaxy Tab S7+ has a much faster processor than the one in my Tab S4, it's the S4 I use in bed to watch video, browse Reddit, and so on. It's "only" 10.5 inches, versus the 12.4 inches of the S7+, and its smaller size makes it a better choice for me. And its Snapdragon 835 is easily more than enough for the activities I use the tablet for.
On the desktop the S7+ is amazing, and I can comfortably use it as a tablet, but I'm not looking for anything larger.
My other tablet is a HTC Flyer from 2011, and HTC hit a home run with its design. Sadly they went with a single core processor and Gingerbread for the OS, later updated to Honeycomb, and that hurt its sales, even tough its performance and HTC customized UI were very good. Just 7 inches in size, and its screen supported using a N-trig stylus. I'd be interested if Samsung went smaller, instead of bigger, with its S (stylus supporting) line of tablets.
Shortage on everything i.e. No more 17 inch laptop (Score:2)
Will you settle for bezel-less screens, and get 16.5? And regarding the other one, you're getting involuntary manslaughter instead of attempted murder, but you'll be out in 5, tops