Multi-drive Ripping / Burning Support? 105
jasonisnuts writes "I currently have a DVD-ROM (internal), a CD-RW (FW), and a DVD-RW (FW), and I also have a massive assortment of music CDs that I want to rip and catalog. Are there any free, shareware, or commercial utilities for Mac OS X that support ripping CDs from multiple devices at the same time and offer full CDDB/GraceNote support? And does this same utility or another offer burning to multiple sources in multiple formats? This will all be done on a Sawtooth 500MHz (upgrading soon)."
iTunes perhaps? (Score:2)
Re:iTunes perhaps? (Score:5, Informative)
more on Sawtooth... (Score:5, Informative)
Re:more on Sawtooth... (Score:2)
then of course, it came out that motorola couldnt provide enough 500's, so they had too do a spedd bump (in the sense of slowing down), 450 became the top of the line, 400 in the middle, and 350 put into yikes boards.
i ordered my 450 the day they were announced and apple tried to charge me more for it, but enough people complained t
Re:more on Sawtooth... (Score:1)
Computer history or what?
Re:iTunes perhaps? (Score:5, Informative)
Re:iTunes perhaps? (Score:3, Interesting)
Can you import and eject from multiple drives simultaneously?
Does anybody know?
Re:iTunes perhaps? (Score:2)
In the preferences, you can set it so that you do not need to click the "import" button. I think (not sitting at my mac right now) that it reads "On CD Insert: Import and eject".
It makes it so that all you need to do is insert a CD. When it is complete, the CD will be ejected. Insert the next CD. If someone's doing mass CD ripping, it's the only way to fly.
If that particular feature worked nicely with multiple drives, you could do a lot of damage with three CD ROM drives a
Re:iTunes perhaps? (Score:2)
You can also burn to multiple drives simultaneously just using the operating system.
No addition software is required.
Re:iTunes perhaps? (Score:3, Informative)
The "Rip CD's in a Row" [malcolmadams.com] script is perfect. I've used it on up to six optical drives at a time without an error.
And yes, I sent him 1
Re:iTunes perhaps? (Score:1)
Justy set the crossfader to zero time - voila, no gap!
Processor and ram (Score:3, Informative)
Re:Processor and ram (Score:2)
Re:Processor and ram (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:Processor and ram (Score:2)
Unfortunate. I'd also been thinking of getting another optical drive (just a decent CD-ROM I could put in the second bay in my mirrored drive door G4) for ripping lots of CDs at once, and I'd wondered how effective the system might be at ripping more than one disc at a time.
Re:Processor and ram (Score:1)
yes, the machine would slow down. however, if the purpose of using multiple drives was to speed things up then this would be counter-productive as far as the original goal was concerned.
as far as multi-disc games go, from my experience the game usually looks in the same location for each disk, ie:
Re:Processor and ram (Score:1)
The OP said that one drive was internal and the other two were firewire. Does this mean he won't suffer from the artifacts and poop that you predict?
Craig
Re:Processor and ram (Score:1)
use more than one application (Score:2, Insightful)
then just set each instance to a different drive, and voila!
it may be better to use a less "intelligent" application than iTunes, as there may be locking issues with updating the iTunes database. however, a simpler ripper should work just fine.
Re:use more than one application (Score:2)
Re:use more than one application (Score:2, Funny)
Looks like Windows users are lending their support.
Re:use more than one application (Score:2)
Re:use more than one application (Score:2, Insightful)
Running a second instance of iTunes from another user account (10.3.x) might work, but you would end up with track info logged in two separate databases.
Re:use more than one application (Score:2)
However, we do share a library, which addresses your first point about the database and the library being fixed. It's a question of permissions and aliases, but once it was done it was nice to have both of us have access to the same library (instead of creating two libraries of the same music).
How useful would this be? (Score:5, Insightful)
Re:How useful would this be? (Score:5, Interesting)
People really underestimate the signal-processing capabilities of these processors. The machines might take their time at day-to-day application use, but when you need to encode video, apply effects, or generally do very multimedia-intensive stuff the G-series CPUs really take Intel and AMD to the cleaner.
Re:How useful would this be? (Score:2, Informative)
On my dual G5 1.8 at home: about 40X going from AIFF-to-MP3. Going to AAC, I get about 28X.
(The AAC encoder isn't multithreaded; it runs on only one CPU at a time.)
Converting from MP3 or AAC to AIFF is the fun part, of course: 150X.
Re:How useful would this be? (Score:1)
Re:How useful would this be? (Score:2)
split that between three drives and its going to be maybe 1.5X tops?
Re:How useful would this be? (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:How useful would this be? (Score:2)
That failing, could he design an AppleScript such that only one CD is ripped at a time? He could queue 3 drives and iTunes could simply go down the line. How scriptable is iTunes, anyway?
Re: (Score:2)
Possible burning solution (Score:5, Informative)
but as for burning, you can use toast. you take the copy you have and make two other copies (AFAIK this is not illegal) open each one and set it to a specific drive.
and on this note, i would assume there it is likely feasible to do something similar with an mp3 ripper, iTunes however, will only allow for one copy to be running at a time.
Running two copies of Toast (Score:2)
We do it all the time when producing short runs of DVDs that would be uneconomical to press.
(A) (B)etter (C)(D) (E)ncoder (Score:5, Informative)
Re:(A) (B)etter (C)(D) (E)ncoder (Score:5, Informative)
From the front page of the site:
Re:(A) (B)etter (C)(D) (E)ncoder (Score:1)
Copy and Rename iTunes (Score:4, Interesting)
If you are running Panther, you could try making two new users, run iTunes in each one and configure each for one of your drives (how, I don't know.. I don't have multiple CD drives - I would assume that the preferences would reflect multiple drives.) and rip away.
That'd be one for you to try.
Other than that - I got nuttin'
Re:Copy and Rename iTunes (Score:1, Informative)
Re:Copy and Rename iTunes (Score:1)
How fast is your fastest drive? (Score:1)
Re:How fast is your fastest drive? (Score:2)
use iTunes, and try this (Score:5, Interesting)
Well, assuming that iTunes meets your other requirements, this AppleScript may prove useful to you:
I haven't used it; I saw it earlier today when grabbing another script from their site. My experience with other Doug's AppleScripts for iTunes has been quite positive. I ripped (in some cases, re-ripped...stupid LAME bug!) all 1500+ or so of my CDs last year, and I used a few of those scripts to make my life easier. Give it a look-through.
Re:use iTunes, and try this (Score:2, Informative)
Isn't replying to your own post a sign of derangement, or something? Anyway....
Something else you might want to check into is a feature that is built-into iTunes. Go to Preferences -> General, and change "On CD Insert" to "Import Songs and Eject." This is a technique that I have used (with multiple optical drives, no less) and can vouch for.
Re:CDeX (Score:2, Funny)
So as a quick run-down on where the right place is to talk about what with GUIs:
slashdot.org - Talk about GUIs some here. Some people will love you and some people wil
Re:CDeX (Score:1)
This info would have saved me weeks of effort, and my karma would now be excellent. You should write the Slashdot for Dummies book.
Re:CDeX (Score:2)
Your CPU will be the bottleneck, not the drives. (Score:4, Insightful)
I don't have multiple CD drives, but perhaps you could test this -- what does iTunes do if you tell it to automatically RIP and eject CD's and you put CD's in multiple drives? I'd guess (since most Apple software is pretty clever) that it would simply work its way through the inserted CD's, in which case you don't need any software -- just load all three of your drives and let iTunes do its work, and stick in new CD's every so often.
Re:Your CPU will be the bottleneck, not the drives (Score:5, Informative)
what does iTunes do if you tell it to automatically RIP and eject CD's and you put CD's in multiple drives?
I did this with a couple Sony Firewire CD-R drives when I was ripping my 1,000+ CD collection. iTunes will dutifully lookup and rip one CD after the other after the other, and all you need to do is keep all the drives full. All having three drives means is that you have to babysit the process 1/3 of the time you would with one drive. This is the way to go, I think.
~jeff
Re:Your CPU will be the bottleneck, not the drives (Score:2)
(Free) easy solution (Score:2, Informative)
Concerning the multiple burning, same solution but I would recommend using the Missing Media Burner [mac.com] (I use 0.6.2 and I'm satisfied). It's not the cleanest apps in the Mac world, but it's free and efficient in burn and overburn, which is quite useful when volume is involved.
Toast is certainly good and is quite a clean app, but it's way too expensive for light
Avoid iTunes (Score:4, Interesting)
Re:Avoid iTunes (Score:2)
1) Old bad
2) Got any references for your claim?
The side-by-side tests that I have seen do not back up your assertion.
A.
Re:Avoid iTunes (Score:2)
Thank you, Slashdot, for throwing away my brackets.
That should be read as 'Old not equal bad'. Yes, I'll preview next time.
A.
Re:Avoid iTunes (Score:4, Funny)
That's what *you* get for being a VB developer... the rest of us would have just used != which even Slashdot understands.
Re:Avoid iTunes (Score:2)
A.
(who programs in Rexx)
Re:Avoid iTunes (Score:3, Informative)
Ah, you want to know my authority for saying it sounds worse? Listening tests I conduc
Re:Avoid iTunes (Score:2)
True but not relevant. It could still be the best encoder on the planet (I don't think it is, but...)
"you want to know my authority for saying it sounds worse? Listening tests I conducted myself."
Ok, a purely subjective observation. That's fine, but one person's opinion isn't going to make me 'Avoid iTunes'.
What I would like to see is more independant data like this:
http://www.sonarnerd.net/projects/wavcomp/
Which st
Re:Avoid iTunes (Score:1)
And yes, blade sucks. But we knew that already.
Re:Avoid iTunes (Score:2)
"The iTunes MP3 encoder was written pretty much from scratch, based on the ISO reference source in distribution 10, as LAME was. I know, I was the principal author (it was originally shipped in SoundJam, for anyone who remembers that far back).
It has been heavily tweaked over the years and doesn't bear much resemblance to dist 10 anymore...
-Bill Kincaid
iTunes"
Re:Avoid iTunes (Score:1)
Note: yes, I would still prefer LAME too because it's highly configurable, but it's foolish to insinuate that iTunes' encoder is inferior in any way w
Re:Avoid iTunes (Score:1)
iTunes is fine. (Score:1, Insightful)
Been there...fixed that (Score:5, Informative)
Terminal utils? Multiple devices per channel? (Score:1)
http://www.xiph.org/paranoia/
really though, this 3-drive thing may very well depend on your hardware configuration, especially if you're using ATA drives, which i assume you are. ripping fr
How much is your time worth? (Score:3, Informative)
Depending on your interests, and your time-/cash-flow, you may decide to pay somebody to rip your CDs for you.
This company...
http://www.ripdigital.com/
Never used 'em.
How much is your time worth? (Score:1)
This company...
http://www.ripdigital.com/ [ripdigital.com]
Never used 'em.
Re:How much is your time worth? (Score:2)
iTunes LAME plugin and multi-processor machines (Score:2, Interesting)
This Applescript plugin for iTunes is really nice. It installs LAME and is very easy to use (just select it from the iTunes script menu). However, it will only allow you to rip one CD at a time per processor, so unless he's got a dualie, this won't help the original poster.
Why not sequential? (Score:2)
Granted this was back on OS 9, and I only had two (internal) drives on my Yosemite, but I just set iTunes up to rip on insert, and eject when done. It'd finish a CD, and I'd pop the next one in my stack in and continue doing what I was doing. It was nice because even if I was off in another room, it would still be crunching away on the next CD, so I kept the processor at 100% all evening long. Took me a week or so (over 100 CDs). I think you'd probably spend more time trying to find software that allows
Here's What I Did: (Score:2)
iTunes would encode one, spit it out, and move to the other. Then I'd pop a new disk in the open drive and the process would repeat.
I haven't done this lately as I've imported most of the CDs I really wanted done already, but I don'
Easiest solution (Score:1, Informative)
Setup iTunes to automatically connect to the internet, and to import and eject each disk automatically. Then feed disks into all three drives. iTunes will rip from each disk in turn and eject it. You can go on about your business and check back
The simplest solution is Finder (Score:2)
When I ripped my CD collection, I used a two-step process. I first ripped the CDs into AIFF. This step is lossless, so there's no quality lost. It does take up some hard drive space, 600-700 megabytes/CD.
Step two: convert these to MP3/AAC/whatever with iTunes or iTunes LAME. The simplest way to do it (in my opinion) is to use
Follow up from the poster (Score:5, Interesting)
By the way.. (Score:1)
Bash script? (Score:1)
Have I missed the point here??
Craig
Use iTunes on two computers (Score:2, Funny)
ripit.pl (Score:2)
Mass Ripping: (Score:2, Informative)
Using iTunes:
1. iTunes, Preferences, General:
--Set "On CD Insert:" to "Import Songs and Eject"
--Check on, "Connect to Internet when needed"
2. iTunes, Preferences, Importing:
--Choose your Import Settings (MP3, AAC, etc) and bit rate. --Check off, "Play songs while importing"
--Check on, "Create file names with track number"
--Check on, "Use error correction when reading Audio CDs" (this will take longer, but if
Do you have a DV or Hi8 camera? (Score:2)
Dv Backup
http://www.coolatoola.com/
Do you expect me to believe... (Score:1)