Tiered Data Plans Coming To the iPhone? 142
jfruhlinger writes "For years analysts have been insisting that Apple must introduce a cheaper iPhone, and soon. So, when Business Week heard that cheaper plans were coming, it reported the news in a positively giddy tone. But, I'm convinced that this is an under-the-radar move to shift to tiered data plans. Everyone who loves their all-you-can-eat iPhone data: enjoy it while it lasts."
economics (Score:5, Insightful)
It would also give O2 a way of offloading all the surplus 3G iPhones cheap in advance of the latest model getting announced in June...
The psychology will be interesting... (Score:5, Insightful)
Given that, I'd be very curious to see how it would fare under a limited data plan. Having to think about the data you are using really crimps the casual and spontaneous nature of the use(just as, when I was on dialup, "being online" was a separate state from "being on the computer" even though the dial-in process only took a couple of minutes, tops. Once I got broadband, even crap DSL, the two became more or less synonymous). If there is a large population that just wants an iPhone for music and/or status, then this should be well recieved. It should also be popular, assuming the price is low enough, with anybody who currently has a touch and a carrier throwaway handset and wants to consolidate.
Outside of those populations, though, an iPhone on a limited data plan seems rather unattractive. Strictly as a phone, the iPhone is merely OK, and pretty damn expensive for what you get. The charm is in what it can do with a data connection. Having to look over your shoulder at your usage all the time would seem to render that less attractive.
Better make sure that phone continues to work. (Score:1, Insightful)
AT&T has been doing that to my mom ever since they changed from AT&T, Cingular and then back to AT&T... Seems my mom was in contract(with automatic renew) for $40.00 a month for 1500 mins. needless to say they wont upgrade her phone, wont help her out without forcing her to make a new contract for less mins (450). Good Bless her she wont.
Re:Bait and switch? (Score:4, Insightful)
Re:economics (Score:5, Insightful)
You're a perfect example of why they don't do it, and why unlimited plans in general survive. You said it yourself, you'd spend half as much on a metered plan. You think that's what they want, for revenue from you to decrease by 50%? That's pure profit; at half the price they'd need 3 or 4 customers to make the same profit because most of the first 15/mo would is "wasted" on, you know, providing service.
Re:The psychology will be interesting... (Score:4, Insightful)
I'm not suggesting that the iPhone should be a platform for fetching the latest Ubuntu ISO on the 3G network. But for AT&T to play like iPhone users have unlimited options to use as much bw as they like is just not reality.
Re:economics (Score:3, Insightful)
Actually, I'm thinking of switching to save money...my current plan is starting to creep over $99/mo. I don't have texting on the current plan from Sprint...and it is starting to cost me as me and my friends are starting to use it more.
Yeah, the tethering things sucks on the iPhone, but, I understand there are ways around out.
But, to me, if I could get the iPhone with unlimited data and texting for the ballpark $80-$90/mo, it would be a good deal to me. I don't have a landline at home anymore, so I only pay cell phone.
Re:tiered data = use it for anything (Score:3, Insightful)
That only works if you assume that "logic", "fair use" and "common sense" are at play here. i.e. I paid for and own my cell phone so I can unlock it and do what I want with it right? (I'm in Canada, so actually I can, but not so much in the US, your mileage may vary by state)
Point being, if you pay for data, it shouldn't matter how that data is used, period. It shouldn't even matter on unlimited plans. Data is data. Everyone here on slashdot understands it, as do the providers, but why not gouge the consumer anyway, it's not like there's a regulatory body in charge of making sure the consumer is protected against this sort of thing... /sarcasm
Re:economics (Score:4, Insightful)
The cheapest plan I've seen with unlimited data is Boost's $50/mo plan, but I don't think you can get a smartphone through Boost, so you're using a less advanced phone with a smaller screen and a telephone keypad for browsing the web, sending emails &c. And that's still $600/year, or $1200/2 years plus taxes, plus phone.
Is there any smartphone/unlimited data phone/plan combination that's significantly less than the iPhone's plans? If the main difference is an extra couple of hundred dollars for the initial iPhone purchase, *that's* what you should be railing against, not the overall cost, which is really really similar between smartphone plans, IMLE.