Apple, the RIAA, and Ringtones 218
pilsner.urquell writes "Apple's interest in defending the rights of the consumer has cost them a lot of grief in the ringtone market. 'John Gruber of the Daring Fireball cites Engadget, which reported that the RIAA wanted to be able to distribute ringtones of its artists without having to pay them big money to do so. It won a decision last year before the Copyright Office saying that ringtones weren't derivative works, meaning they didn't infringe on the copyright of the songwriter.' The piece goes on to explain the tense relationship between Apple content holders regarding ringtones and other pieces of IP, such as in the recent withdrawal of NBC."
So, it's free? (Score:5, Interesting)
Wait, they own what? (Score:5, Interesting)
According to TFA, they won a decision not in court, but simply at the Copyright Office. I don't see any links to this decision itself, and I don't have time to search for it with the insignificant amount of information we are given, so I don't have any idea what this actually says... But I can't see how the Copyright Office is able to give distribution rights other than the information that something is or is not covered under copyright law. They cannot say it's not copyrighted and then authorize the RIAA to collect money, and they can't say it's copyrighted and give the RIAA permission to ignore it and not pay the copyright owner.
Anyone got any more -real- information, instead of just a link to site that links to a site that claims something that isn't cited at all?
Re:I never knew copyright law was THIS broken (Score:3, Interesting)
Well, somehow this rule seems to apply to Apple phones only. Most other phones will be happy to play anything playable as a ringer.
Note to consumers: Don't pay for ringtones! Help stop those stupid commercials on TV by making their business model fail. This might be one of the rare occasions where an organized boycott might actually make sense and work out fine.
Defense? (Score:4, Interesting)
We argue estopel, and the defense rests.
Re:Entertainment Cartels Want it All (Score:5, Interesting)