Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
Music Businesses Media Apple Your Rights Online

Apple To Play Fairer With FairPlay? 153

Posted by kdawson
from the all's-fair dept.
NewbieMonster writes "According to tech.co.uk, Apple is about to license its Fairplay DRM to Made for iPod accessory manufacturers. It's reported that Apple will also allow streaming of protected AAC content via USB. Could this signal a move to allowing other music players to access and play ITMS content?" From the article: "The expected announcements could signal a move on Apple's part to take some of the sting out of its Fairplay DRM which has come in for a great deal of criticism over recent months. It may also be a way of keeping Made For iPod makers onside, as the draw of the Microsoft Zune becomes stronger." Anyone noticed the draw of the Microsoft Zune becoming stronger?
This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.

Apple To Play Fairer With FairPlay?

Comments Filter:
  • by User 956 (568564) on Tuesday January 16, 2007 @10:23PM (#17640358) Homepage
    The labels require it though (also to maintain control over your music unless you are living under a rock somewhere and wonder why about that too)... why not use it to your company's advantage when the people your licensing from require it anyway.

    That's false, and Apple loves that you believe it. The license holders don't "require it". Case-in-point, eMusic, which sells DRM-free MP3's [boingboing.net]. A ton of them. Johnny Cash, Dashboard Confessional, Credence Clearwater, Moby, the list goes on for miles.

    Those songs are DRM-free on eMusic, but on iTunes, those same songs are locked down with Apple's Fairplay. The only one making that decision is Apple, and the only reason they make that decision is to lock in marketshare.
  • Re:No (Score:4, Interesting)

    by cbrocious (764766) on Wednesday January 17, 2007 @03:14AM (#17642820) Homepage
    All that needs to be done to make PyMusique again is to reverse-engineer the algorithm used to encrypt the store pages behind ssl, the algorithm that manipulates their keys, and the simple algorithm used to encrypt the files as they're transferred from the store (before per-user DRM is applied).

    Not very difficult at all, just a bit time consuming.

    (From the original author of PyTunes, which PyMusique is a GUI frontend to :P )
  • by DaveCar (189300) on Wednesday January 17, 2007 @06:45AM (#17643870)

    Then how do you explain that *all* the labels on iTunes sell *all* that music in a higher quality (ie. not lossily compressed) unprotected form? It's called a CD.

    DRM is pushed by tech companies like a narcotic and some music labels are stupid enough to buy into it.

    It will *always* be possible for content to end up on the P2P networks in a "good enough" (for 95% of the audience) form anyway, and as soon as one person does it that nixes the value of the DRM to the label anyway.

    Some labels might "want" DRM, but it is the illusion that they are buying, not the reality.
  • Re:iPod != Fair Play (Score:4, Interesting)

    by DrXym (126579) on Wednesday January 17, 2007 @07:05AM (#17643950)
    And the Zune, PS3 and PSP will play unencrypted MP3 and AAC too. Still doesn't help if you bought something from iTMS and now discover that it's bound to Apple-only devices and you can NEVER play it on anything else except by circumventing the DRM.

    The moral here is that stores that encrypt music or tie them to a device suck. I really don't understand why music publishers want DRM at all. All that happens with lock-in is that somebody like Apple dominates the market and then the music industry is compelled to dance to their tune. If you level the playing field by publishing music without restrictions, then you can set your own price, since if Apple won't meet your price, then somebody else sure as hell will. Consumers win out too since they can get their music from dozens of sites and use them on dozens of their own devices. I doubt the amount of piracy would change significantly either since albums can be had right now on P2P, so what difference does it make if there is DRM or not?

We are experiencing system trouble -- do not adjust your terminal.

Working...