Become a fan of Slashdot on Facebook

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×
Media (Apple) Businesses Media Music Apple

Ars Technica's iPod nano Dissection 532

starwindsurfer wrote to mention an Ars Technica review of the iPod nano in which they autopsy the cute little guy to find out what makes him tick. A more thorough review than the one we ran last week. From the article: "At this point we were astounded that the iPod nano was still working properly, albeit with a broken display. Because we had honestly expected the iPod nano to break by this time, we were forced to depart from our planned schedule of destruction and try and run over it with the car. Surely, we thought, it could never withstand the crushing power of German automotive engineering." Update: 09/12 14:58 GMT by Z : Changed linking words to previous article for clarity. Monday fuzziness.
This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.

Ars Technica's iPod nano Dissection

Comments Filter:
  • by furiousx ( 909573 ) on Monday September 12, 2005 @10:33AM (#13537686)
    also refer to the outstanding battery life?
  • by rAiNsT0rm ( 877553 ) on Monday September 12, 2005 @10:33AM (#13537692) Homepage
    Seriously, I find it funny how as soon as we get some new piece of technology our first instinct is to break it. Honestly think about it. I can't tell you how many things I can't wait to take apart as soon as I buy it. There has to be somehting unhealthy about this.

    Give somehting new and unknown to a bunch of apes and the first thing they do is smash it or rip it apart inquisitively.

    Guess we ain't so superior after all. :)
  • Dead Cat (Score:5, Funny)

    by Anonymous Coward on Monday September 12, 2005 @10:39AM (#13537732)
    If you open up a cat to see how it works, the first thing you have is a non-working cat.
  • by mblase ( 200735 ) on Monday September 12, 2005 @10:41AM (#13537747)
    What they should consentrate on is making it scratch proof, I can't stand so many scratches. Cases do not work so well, they still scratch and add lots of bulk.

    Small, rugged, scratchproof: pick any two?

    Tell you what: if you buy an itty-bitty iPod nano and still think it's too bulky after adding a sleeve around it, I will personally come to your house and sew bigger pockets onto all your clothes.
  • by mattyohe ( 517995 ) <matt.yohe@g m a i l.com> on Monday September 12, 2005 @10:42AM (#13537748)
    That was a bit confusing on a Monday morning... You linked the words "more thorough review" to point to the less thorough review.
  • by Schezar ( 249629 ) on Monday September 12, 2005 @10:45AM (#13537770) Homepage Journal
    Just the other day, I was planning a mountain biking excursion with my flatemate. He'd never been mountain biking before, and he somehow got it into his head that bringing his Ipod Mini would be a good idea.

    I tried to convince him that he would break it via collision with rocks or maybe a tree. He claimed that it was a very durable piece of hardware.

    To demonstrate, he dropped it to the carpeted floor and bopped it with his foot...

    The display shattered.

    I think I laughed for a good half-hour. I felt bad about it, but there's nothing you can do but laugh when something so perfectly comedically timed happens.

    It wasn't all bad. He just used this as an excuse to buy the new Nano.
  • by thc69 ( 98798 ) on Monday September 12, 2005 @10:47AM (#13537790) Homepage Journal
    That's what makes us so superior. If I hadn't taken schitt apart when I was a little geekling, I would never have blossomed into the well rounded geek I am today. Hell, now I can even put stuff back together!
  • by Anonymous Coward on Monday September 12, 2005 @10:48AM (#13537792)
    --> we were forced to depart from our planned schedule of destruction and try and run over it with the car. Surely, we thought, it could never withstand the crushing power of German automotive engineering --

    Will you please please run a review on my Mother-In-Law ??? Gratitudes in advance.
  • by op12 ( 830015 ) on Monday September 12, 2005 @10:48AM (#13537798) Homepage
    Give somehting new and unknown to a bunch of apes and the first thing they do is smash it or rip it apart inquisitively.

    Guess we ain't so superior after all. :)


    But now we can also run things over with cars...so clearly we've evolved. No more pounding on it with large rocks.
  • by furiousx ( 909573 ) on Monday September 12, 2005 @10:51AM (#13537829)
    13 hours before stops holding a charge? That IS an improvement!
  • by op12 ( 830015 ) on Monday September 12, 2005 @10:52AM (#13537838) Homepage
    Tell you what: if you buy an itty-bitty iPod nano and still think it's too bulky after adding a sleeve around it, I will personally come to your house and sew bigger pockets onto all your clothes.

    I added the sleeve and it's still too bulky. I'll be expecting you at my house at 8am sharp tomorrow.
  • Nerds (Score:5, Funny)

    by z0l0pht ( 835541 ) on Monday September 12, 2005 @10:59AM (#13537890)
    "For our second test, one of us held on to the iPod, jogged about 20 feet" ...which is the average distance a nerd can jog
  • by rAiNsT0rm ( 877553 ) on Monday September 12, 2005 @11:13AM (#13538000) Homepage
    So, basically, to sum it up. We've created a whole bunch of advanced shit to take apart and more advanced shit to *use* to take the advanced shit apart... all while being comfortable.

    Man, we sure have come a long way! :)
  • by Vorondil28 ( 864578 ) on Monday September 12, 2005 @11:15AM (#13538017) Journal
    After they ran it over with the car....
     
    ...the iPod's display was not cracked but was showing some nasty vertical lines. Shockingly, the nano was still playing music and the controls still operated as expected, as we were still able to skip ahead, go back, pause, and play music!

    So basically, VW + Nano = Shuffle?
  • by rAiNsT0rm ( 877553 ) on Monday September 12, 2005 @11:16AM (#13538022) Homepage
    Yeah, RUNNING SHIT OVER WITH A CAR helps us understand a whole bunch of new things that otherwise would have gone unknown. Damn am I dumb, how could I have overlooked that!
  • by SimilarityEngine ( 892055 ) on Monday September 12, 2005 @11:17AM (#13538037)

    even if you keep it in a sock you still get those little scartches

    Not to mention a somewhat cheesy music collection.

  • Re:Dead Cat (Score:1, Funny)

    by Anonymous Coward on Monday September 12, 2005 @11:25AM (#13538097)
    My experiments in this area have been extensive.
    Why not replace the toast with _another_ cat strapped back to back with the first? They seem to enter chaotic oscillation without actually needing to be dropped from a building. Actually the cat(s) shouldn't be dead unless you building a Schrodinger quantum antigravity device. By extention two pieces of buttered toast should have the same properties, but the cat device is 9 times more robust. A silmilar effect can be achieved using only one cat of the surface it stands on is heated. Because any such anti-grav device has rotational stability issues a box must be constructed around the cats for a practical device. Airholes for the cats to breathe allow photons into and out of the box causing each of the cats to become 50% dead when observed and the antigrav device falls to the ground. Once I find the right permeable opaque material and some more cats it's space here I come.
  • Re:Summary (Score:5, Funny)

    by ifwm ( 687373 ) on Monday September 12, 2005 @11:30AM (#13538148) Journal
    "It is too small"

    What kind of complaint is this?

    "I can't believe how small this thing that's supposed to be small is. Can you believe they actually made this small thing so small?"

    Next you'll be comlpaining about Ferraris

    "I can't believe how fast this thing is. Why would they want to make a car that's supposed to be fast this fast? Stupid Ferrari..."
  • Re:Dead Cat (Score:5, Funny)

    by inkdesign ( 7389 ) on Monday September 12, 2005 @11:44AM (#13538292)
    He's still alive in the other universe where you're not a sicko..
  • by rAiNsT0rm ( 877553 ) on Monday September 12, 2005 @11:48AM (#13538332) Homepage
    Actually made me laugh out loud. Good Jorb :)

    I love when people do dumb shit. Nothing is funnier.

    I once watched a guy claim his new 4WD Subaru could climb up a huge dirt pile. So he did it to prove it, problem was once on the crest of a pile of soft dirt your tires sink in and your screwed. He had to pay the people who had the dirt pile to dig out dirt around it slowly so it eventually could be driven out.

    I also watched a guy at an airport with one of those Panasonic Toughbooks stand on top of it (while closed) to impress a woman at the airport bar (way to get chicks) and then he opened the display and turned it on to reveal a nicely mangled LCD panel. Even the bartender laughed his ass off.
  • by RapmasterT ( 787426 ) on Monday September 12, 2005 @12:04PM (#13538463)
    What they should consentrate on is making it scratch proof, I can't stand so many scratches.
    They should make the case of aluminum and hard annodize it, that would be pretty much scratchproof.


    Hell, I discovered with my calphalon cookware that if you hard annodize aluminum, and then stir-fry zucchini in it, you'll end up with an indestructable and permanent coating that could protect space shuttles during re-entry. Who the F*CK thought non-nonstick cookware was a good idea ???? :-(

  • by mjpaci ( 33725 ) * on Monday September 12, 2005 @12:04PM (#13538464) Homepage Journal
    Wrap it in plastic wrap* -- it's cheap and you can buy it anywhere!

    * I high-school intern we had last summer wrapped his 20GB iPod in plastic wrap. When I asked him why, he said, "Because I'm Chinese. We wrap everything in plastic wrap. You should see the remote controls..." Flabergasted, I looked over at another intern, also Chinese, who was nodding in agreement. I thought nothing of it, ok that's a lie, until I went into the local Chinese take-out place the other day and saw their cash register wrapped in Saran-wrap.
  • by qray ( 805206 ) on Monday September 12, 2005 @12:06PM (#13538483)
    Remember to take off your diamond wedding ring when you go to rub your eyes.

    ---
    gyram gritru bocnor rofa
  • by Dogtanian ( 588974 ) on Monday September 12, 2005 @12:18PM (#13538588) Homepage
    Is that an iPod in your pocket or are you just happy to see me?

    Not with the iPod Nano, presumably.

    "Is that an iPod Nano in your pocket, or do you just have a small penis?"
  • by Anonymous Coward on Monday September 12, 2005 @12:53PM (#13538849)
    To demonstrate, he dropped it to the carpeted floor and bopped it with his foot...

    The display shattered.

    I was at an Apple Executive Briefing a few years ago when the white iBook was brand new. One of the employees was using one to take notes. The Apple exec giving the presentation wanted to show how sturdy it was, so he took the iBook and dropped it on the floor, and the screen cracked. It was still working fine (this was to demonstrate that the little rubber bumpers that held the HD in place were good at shock absorption, and they were), but it was a bit hard to use with a big crack down the middle. The best part? It was the employees personal laptop, not a company one. Needless to say, it was taken away to get a new screen on the spot. The executive was quite embarrassed.

  • by fideli ( 861469 ) on Monday September 12, 2005 @12:58PM (#13538903)
    I'll be expecting you at my house at 8am sharp tomorrow.
    Absolutely. Please provide me with your name, address, daytime and evening phone number, as well as two pieces of identification (including a valid credit card, preferably) and for verification purposes we also need your SIN or SSN number.
  • by Anonymous Coward on Monday September 12, 2005 @01:06PM (#13538983)

    From TFA:

    The iPod nano; especially for women who have very little pocket space and are much more adverse to carrying bulkier electronics in those pockets than men.

    Wasn't this solved last April with the Apple iPad [boakes.org]?

  • by Anonymous Coward on Monday September 12, 2005 @01:12PM (#13539035)
    "...Because I'm Chinese. We wrap everything in plastic wrap..."
    This is true; I went out with a lady from Beijing last year, and her idea of birth control... well...

    Little wonder that China has such a large population.
  • Re:Dead Cat (Score:2, Funny)

    by johnw ( 3725 ) on Monday September 12, 2005 @01:23PM (#13539107)
    Whereas *until* you open the cat it's in an indeterminate state.

    John
  • by idlake ( 850372 ) on Monday September 12, 2005 @01:25PM (#13539123)
    I high-school intern

    You Chinese too?
  • by tsa ( 15680 ) on Monday September 12, 2005 @01:43PM (#13539276) Homepage
    I once saw a discussion on a German forum that went just like this, but just a little further. All of a sudden the guy that gave all the data complained about someone buying a lot of computers off his credit card. After that one of the moderators removed the data from the website. Since /. policy is never to remove data, I wonder if they would make an exception in this case ;-)
  • by usernotfound ( 831691 ) on Monday September 12, 2005 @02:03PM (#13539449)
    in 500 + miles of mountain biking in arizona, my zen has never complained of the sweat, heat, and my 180 lbs landing on it and rolling at 30 mph. it's really weird to regain conciousness with The Mar Volta blasting in your ears.
  • by Anonymous Coward on Monday September 12, 2005 @02:06PM (#13539471)
    From TFA:

    Lacking a really high place to drop the nano from, we decided the throw the nano as high as we could, say 40 feet into the air, and let it land--hard--on the concrete.

    Considering how geeky the guys at Ars Technica are, I was surprised they got it more than 5 feet in the air...
  • by mangu ( 126918 ) on Monday September 12, 2005 @02:07PM (#13539476)
    that's not a coin pocket, Levi Strauss designed it for matches when he created the jean for miners to keep the matches dry.


    Yes, I can see why Levi Strauss had the name of the small pocket changed. Imagine a 19th century TV ad for Levi's:

    In the foreground an old man, played by Mel Brooks, is holding a pair of jeans.

    "...and this small pocket here is great for holding matc..."

    In the background, a miner is entering a coal mine. He has an unlighted cigarette in his mouth and is patting his pockets for matches. He enters the coal mine as his right hand finds the small pocket.

    ***BOOM***

    Camera turns back to the salesman:

    "...coins! This small pocket is great for holding coins!"

  • by grahams ( 5366 ) * on Monday September 12, 2005 @02:10PM (#13539503) Homepage
    Remember to take off your diamond wedding ring when you go to rub your eyes.
    Slashdot readers do not have such problems.
  • by ameline ( 771895 ) <ian.ameline@ g m a i l .com> on Monday September 12, 2005 @02:11PM (#13539507) Homepage Journal
    It's true

    I once knew a guy (who is Korean) who wrapped his remotes in plastic wrap. I thoughtfully took out the batteries and similarly protected them (being careful to cover the terminals too :-), and put them back in the remotes.

    I wish I could have seen his face when he found it. (He probably didn't think it was funny.)

    Charles? Are you reading this? It was me -- I did it.

    Back on topic -- The one thing I don't like about my ipod is its propensity to collect scratches. Could they not have used a more scratch resisant material? I guess not.

  • by Tim Browse ( 9263 ) on Monday September 12, 2005 @03:13PM (#13540017)
    The secret is to bang the iPods together, guys!
  • by fbg111 ( 529550 ) on Monday September 12, 2005 @03:16PM (#13540039)
    Is that an iPod in your pocket or are you just happy to see me?

    Hopefully, for your sake, it's an iPod.

    [Notice Apple's comparison of Nano to a pencil... [apple.com]]
  • by Loether ( 769074 ) on Monday September 12, 2005 @03:23PM (#13540113) Homepage
    In high school I was showing off my new car alarm to my buddy. I said see you just barely hit it and the alarm goes off. I lightly hit it... no effect. I hit it a little bit harder... and dented the car. The alarm never went off. He laughed his ass off. I didn't find it as amusing at the time.
  • by Anonymous Coward on Monday September 12, 2005 @03:43PM (#13540285)
    Technocrat #1: My iPod is so small, I can fit it in my ear!

    Technocrat #2: MY iPod is so small it fits in a single cell IN MY BRAIN.

    Technocrat #3: *My* iPod is so small that it actually uses coding added to my own DNA, letting me use all my cells for storage!

    Technocrat #4: (Wearing huge black gloves connected to a metal backpack) *My* iPod has negative mass. It requires a magnetic containment field to hold.
  • by Anonymous Coward on Monday September 12, 2005 @06:32PM (#13541837)
    Slashdot readers do not have such problems

    However, the calluses on their hands can have the same effect...
  • by Durf ( 866206 ) on Monday September 12, 2005 @10:34PM (#13543459)
    Quick, patent that idea before Apple starts stir-frying zucchini on the second-generation iPod Nanos to toughen 'em up.

Long computations which yield zero are probably all for naught.

Working...